User talk:MessedRocker

I like the idea of having a neutral description page when there is more than one review of something. --JWSchmidt 17:19, 12 Nov 2005 (UTC)

I have no objection to having editors set up a neutral description page when there is only one review or even when there is not yet any review. However, it should not be required that a person who writes a review also creates a neutral description page. I do not want to see the creation of any extra work for reviewers. It is already hard enough to attract contributors. --JWSchmidt 17:29, 12 Nov 2005 (UTC)

Hello. I'm removing the link to the proposal on meta from the main page. Firstly, the discussion there is very inactive. Also, the reason this was accepted as a Wikia site is because we feel it wouldn't be appropriate for Wikimedia. We aim to not duplicate Wikimedia's goals of producing general reference material, so a review site, based on opinions rather than being educational, fits Wikia's goals, but not Wikimedia's. As explained in the Wikimedia Foundation bylaws, their purpose is to develop informational databases, and I don't believe opinion is part of that. Angela (talk) 11:24, 22 April 2006 (UTC)